Adding to the Pack: Considerations for Getting a Second Dog

One dog is good; two is better; three is just a party at the Mos Eisley Cantina waiting to happen! (#hanshotfirst) But hold your paws there, my dear friend, because with every new addition to the family comes new challenges, especially when getting a second dog. Remember that more pets also means more chaos, more mess, and more...well, just more. 

The eternal dilemma of the pet lover: to adopt or not to adopt? More specifically, to get a second dog or not to get a second dog?

The eternal dilemma of the pet lover: to adopt or not to adopt? More specifically, to get a second dog or not to get a second dog?

Max and Domino in 2008

As any pet parent will tell you, the temptation to add furry friends to the household is a strong Force. After all, who wouldn't want a pack of lovable canines following them around? For me, the answer to both questions was a resounding yes! It was like Din Djarin adopted Grogu and then added another Grogu to the pack! The years Max and Domino were with us were the best and it was my privilege to care for them.

So, while the idea of a second dog may sound like a dream come true, it's essential to prepare yourself for the challenges that come with it. There is a chance you could end up adding a Jar Jar! Let's delve into the double-dog-dom world and ensure you're ready for the adventure.

Wrong reasons to get a second dog

First and foremost, we should evaluate our intentions before getting a second dog. Here are some wrong reasons that you must avoid if your decision is based on them:

  • To keep your current dog company

While it's true that dogs are social animals, getting a second dog solely to keep your current dog company may not be the best idea. It's essential to ensure both dogs have compatible personalities and get along well.

  • Because your kids want one

Children may beg for a second dog, but it's important to remember that dogs require a lot of time, attention, and resources. If you're not ready to commit to a second dog, it's best to hold off.

Adding a Second Dog to Your Pack

PUHLEEAAAASSE!!!

  • To fill a void

If you find yourself grappling with the absence of a beloved furry friend, you may be tempted to fill the void by bringing another adorable pup into your life. While the idea of a new four-legged companion is undoubtedly appealing, it's crucial to ensure that you're prepared for the emotional responsibilities that come with pet ownership. Pet loss grief is very real. “When you lose a pet, you lose a family member. It takes a piece of your heart you cannot get back.” If you find yourself in this inevitable yet sad situation, C. Jeffrey’s Amazon Audible book,  Repairing the Heartbreak of Pet Loss Grief: 3 Phases of Healing After Losing Your Best Friend may be of comfort to you.

Rushing into a new pet to fill the gap left by your previous one may leave you feeling unfulfilled and your new furry friend potentially unloved.

  • Because it's cute

Getting a second dog just because you saw a cute puppy or dog may not be the best idea. It's essential to consider factors such as breed, temperament, and energy level to ensure the dog is a good fit for your family and lifestyle.

Puppy Toys on Amazon

Pros and cons of getting a second dog

Pros and cons of getting a second dog

Following are the advantages of getting a second dog:

  • Companionship: A second dog can provide companionship for your existing dog, reducing their loneliness and boredom when you're not around.

  • Exercise: Having two dogs can motivate you to take them for more walks, runs, or playtime, which benefits their physical and mental health.

  •  Training: When a new dog is introduced to a household, it can be an excellent opportunity for both dogs to learn new behaviors and socialize.

  • Reduce Separation Anxiety: A second dog can help alleviate separation anxiety in dogs who struggle alone.

  • Fun: Watching two dogs play and interact with each other can be enjoyable for you and your family and can provide entertainment for your dogs as well.

Following are the cons that you should consider before getting a second dog.

  • Expense: Just ask my bank account in the early 2000’s! Having two dogs means doubling the cost of food, veterinary care, and other supplies. Especially as they get older. You can spend literally thousands of dollars on medical expenses for elderly dogs.

  • Dominance: A second dog can challenge your existing dog's authority, which may lead to aggression or territorial behavior.

  • Space: A second dog will require additional space in your home, which may be challenging if you live in a small apartment or have limited outdoor space.

  •  Time: Especially if you work full time! Caring for two dogs requires more time and energy than one, especially regarding training, exercising, and grooming. 

  • Health Issues: A second dog can increase the risk of spreading illnesses or parasites between dogs, especially if they are not adequately vaccinated or treated for fleas and ticks.

BarkBox is a monthly delivery of unique toys and all-naturaltreats and chewers inspired by a new theme, tailored to your dog,and shipped free to your door, every month.

BarkBox is a monthly delivery of unique toys and all-natural
treats and chewers inspired by a new theme, tailored to your dog,
and shipped free to your door, every month.

FAQs

  1. How will I introduce the new puppy?

Introducing a new puppy to a resident dog requires patience and careful supervision. Start by presenting them in neutral territory and gradually move towards raising them in the home. Supervise all interactions and reward good behavior. Ensure each dog has their own space and resources to prevent conflict.

2. What's the best time to get a second dog?

Deciding when to get a second dog requires careful consideration of several factors. The age and temperament of the current dog(s) should be considered, as well as the family's lifestyle and available resources. It's crucial to ensure that the existing dog(s) are well-trained and socialized before introducing a new dog into the household. 

The family's schedule should also be considered, as a second dog will require additional time and attention. Additionally, financial resources should be considered, as the cost of caring for two dogs can be significant. 

Ultimately, there is no "right" time to get a second dog, but careful planning can increase the chances of success and a smooth transition for both dogs.

3. How will I feel about a second dog?

It's common for pet owners to experience feelings of guilt or uncertainty when adding a new dog to their household. Remember that these feelings are normal and can be overcome with proper scheduling and planning. By taking the time to introduce the new dog gradually and making sure each dog has their own space and attention, pet owners can help ensure a smooth transition for everyone involved.

Conclusion

Don’t find yourself stepping in Bantha fodder! Getting a second dog can be a wonderful experience for both you and your current furry friend. However, it's vital to ensure that you're making this decision for the right reasons. Wrong reasons, such as getting a second dog solely to provide companionship for your current dog, can lead to unexpected challenges and potentially harm the bond between your pets. 

With proper planning and preparation, bringing a new puppy into your home can be a joyous experience for everyone involved. Introducing a new puppy to your household can be a gradual process, allowing your current dog and the new puppy to become comfortable with each other before allowing them to interact freely. By approaching the decision to get a second dog thoughtfully and responsibly, you can create a happy and harmonious home for your furry family.

 

This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase an item after clicking a link, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. I donate a percentage of my commissions monthly to online pet charities like Florida Urgent Rescue, Inc., and that amount is well over 400% of my online income LOL - so anything you can do, much appreciated!

Hi, I’m Mona, a Gainesville, Florida pet sitter. I love family, pets, blogging, looking at pet photos online for hours (I never get tired of seeing pictures of your fur babies,) Star Wars, SciFi, Halloween and Halloween Horror Nights. When I’m not pet sitting, I have even ventured into doing some travelling lately.

Rover, the world’s largest network of 5-star pet sitters and dog walkers

New to Rover.com ? First time users can receive $20 off their first booking fee by applying promo code MONAB20831.

View my profile on Rover here!

 
Previous
Previous

Finding the Right Pet Sitter: A Guide to Choosing the Best Caregiver for Your Furry Friend

Next
Next

Keeping Your Furry Friends Hydrated: A Guide to Proper Dog and Cat Hydration